Civil disobedience means breaking a law believed to be immoral and unjust like thoreau, i believe civil disobedience can be justified and it is our duty as citizens to stand up for what we believe. So, we could argue that people who break the law in acts of civil disobedience are in fact demonstrating responsible citizenship and the highest form of civic virtue but, when, if ever, is one justified in taking the step from expression of opinion to breaking the law. Category archives: argumentative essay 091713 by jill pavich presentations, day 1: essay connections can breaking the law ever be justified.
(king) king went on in his letter to say that it would be against man made law to help a jew in nazi germany what king said in his letter has to make a person think that not all laws are good for the group in society and morality is a justifiable excuse in breaking the law dr. Law, we do not need a special justification for breaking it this doesn't automatically mean civil disobedience would always be justified, but that justifying it is no different. Can breaking the law ever be justified there were times in history when breaking the law was justified: great leaders like gandhi and martin luther king broke the law and changed the world for the better.
Hence sometimes, breaking the law can be justified breaking the rules can be the best thing to do in a particular situation it may not be right according to the rules but it might be what the best thing to do is. There are two situations where it is justifiable to break a law: when following the law leads to greater harm than breaking it, and when the law itself is unjust if i were starving, i would have no problem stealing food death is a greater harm than property loss there have been many, many unjust laws throughout history. Can terrorism ever be justified since the turn of the century, the postmodern world has seen increasing levels of political, cultural, military and socio-economic tumult, much of this due to a series of terrorist attacks on american soil and the resultant waging of washington 's war on terror. In many cases, breaking the law will hinder the cause rather than further it those who chose to break the law, even for justified reasons, must be ready to face the consequences list cite. Certain circumatances for breaking the law in order to help another would be to break the law for civil freedoms and liberties, and to break the law, thou shall not kill, in order to defend another.
Question: is breaking the law ever justified posted on december 20, 2011 by neal some of you are probably already asking if the title of this article is some kind of a joke, or a trick question. Can breaking the law ever be justified term papers available at planetpaperscom, the largest free term paper community. Second, since civil disobedience is normally designed to attract public attention, it can lead people, as a result, to think of resorting to disobedience to achieve whatever changes in law or policy they find justified (raz 1979, 262.
Are we ever morally justified in disobeying laws we consider to be immoral the answer to this question depends very much on our understanding and opinion on the status of the law on this issue it is likely that everyone falls into one of two broad categories. To determine whether or not breaking a law would be justified rawls believed that there must be a clear injustice, the act of disobedience must be a public act which is both non-violent and non. Infractions of state law can be neatly categorized into one of two sets: the first is common crime, and the second, the more complex, civil disobedience crime is simply the breaking of any law under any circumstances - and as such civil disobedience must also be seen as a special case of crime.
It is possible, in the us, to break a law, be brought to trial, and still be acquitted, but only if the jury feels the law is bad, in which case it can be removed from the books, or nullified. It may be confined to breaking only particular laws which are considered unjust, as in the civil rights movement in the usa in the 1960s alternatively civil disobedience can include breaking other laws as a way of drawing attention to the perceived injustice, for example by damage to property, non-payment of fines or taxes, obstruction of building work, and trespassing. Can breaking the law ever be justified, morally or ethically in his situation, king discusses how many other countries are moving forward in how they develop and treat others he criticizes the united states as they creep forward with the pace of a horse and buggy when it comes to civil rights. This lesson plan is designed to be used in conjunction with the film the camden 28, which chronicles the actions of a group of anti-vietnam war activists known as the camden 28 in 1971, the group.